Back to the bookshelf

Typographic jacket · original cover not fetched

FROM THE SHARED SHELF · 2006–2026 SAMPLE

Nations: The Long History and Deep Roots of Political Ethnicity

Azar Gat

1 reader recommends it across 1 discussion

Topics are model-inferred labels.

Keep it on your reading list

THE WORD OF MOUTH

What made it worth passing on?

Original Hacker News comments, in the readers’ own words.

barry-cotter
> Imagined Communities - the notion of a "nation" is only 300 years old and has no objective basis, only the fact that a group of people agree that it is a thing. The Lombards, Saxons, Franks, Magyars, Mongols and many, many others would disagree. And the Khmer, Mon, Viet and Tai. https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2018/03/26/communities-only-e... (https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2018/03/26/communities-only-exist-only-in-the-minds-of-europeans/) > Overall it is worth reading Imagined Communities because of its purported cultural significance. But much of it is so garbled and unclear I’m not sure what people are taking from it, aside from the proposition that the modern nation-state was invented in the last few centuries due to modernity. In the end the book is kind of a long tautology. Azar Gat’s Nations is a far superior book.

Also recommended in this reply